Denied WaterSpring (Used only by waterbottles)

[HydroMan]

@Pickle9775 whats your take on this?

 

[Pickle9775]

Well. I see the need for this move, water's main weakness being a lack of mobility. I think the move poses a possible answer to this issue, but I see two main issues.

1. The move would have too few uses aside from getting out of a tight spot such as EarthGrab
2. It would require bottle bending to use, and thus would require items, and a large portion of people who use bending use it in a PVP arena where this isn't possible.

Side note: making WaterWave bottlebendable wouldn't be wise because then people could spam it and basically fly.

 

[HydroMan]

2. It would require bottle bending to use, and thus would require items, and a large portion of people who use bending use it in a PVP arena where this isn't possible.

Side note: making WaterWave bottlebendable wouldn't be wise because then people could spam it and basically fly.

Well i would say thats not a really issue, as why would we then have bottlebending for... Its for using it. On the arena i have been ,most of them include bottles for waterbenders to take with them..

You have a very good point why waterwave shouldn't be possible though.

 

[Pickle9775]

Well i would say thats not a really issue, as why would we then have bottlebending for... Its for using it. On the arena i have been ,most of them include bottles for waterbenders to take with them..

You have a very good point why waterwave shouldn't be possible though.

Okay but issue 1 still stands though. It doesn't have many other uses.

 

[HydroMan]

Okay but issue 1 still stands though. It doesn't have many other uses.

Well WaterManipulation can only hit stuff so..it also has 1 use :/

 

[Pickle9775]

Well WaterManipulation can only hit stuff so..it also has 1 use :/

Because it's the basic attack. Every element has its own version of it.

 

[paliate]

Theres a reason you can't waterwave with bottles, either way this isn't a swell idea.
Either way i've never seen a waterbender "spring" up with a bottle?

(going to wait for a response before i mark it)

 

[Finn_Bueno_]

Theres a reason you can't waterwave with bottles, either way this isn't a swell idea.
Either way i've never seen a waterbender "spring" up with a bottle?

(going to wait for a response before i mark it)

oh I have.
Using bottlebending to get yourself out of something or to jump over something is canon. I suck at making GIfs, but there is an episode where katara makes a little sort of bridge with the water in her bottle, which she uses to jemp, and then the uses the water to push of the earthbenders.

 

[paliate]

I believe she used the water from the river for the bridge and the water from her bottle to attack them, (could be wrong but i haven't seen a gif yet, nor do i recall exactly what source she used)

 

[Hero]

I believe she used the water from the river for the bridge and the water from her bottle to attack them, (could be wrong but i haven't seen a gif yet, nor do i recall exactly what source she used)

Nope, I know what hes talking about.

She takes water from her water bottle and makes a ramp of ice, then she uses her leg to grab water from the river and use water whip with her legs.

BOOM! ITS CANON. NOW LETS MAKE THIS?! @finnbon, I gotz you...

 

[HydroMan]

Nope, I know what hes talking about.

She takes water from her water bottle and makes a ramp of ice, then she uses her leg to grab water from the river and use water whip with her legs.

BOOM! ITS CANON. NOW LETS MAKE THIS?! @finnbon, I gotz you...

Not that its the same, as my idea was about water to spring once its fully charge ,but the aspect of a mobility move being bottlebendable

 

[Taiko the Waterbender]

Not that its the same, as my idea was about water to spring once its fully charge ,but the aspect of a mobility move being bottlebendable

Also, Katara was runnung and shs had free space to move her arms... This idea takes as base that you are stuck in a m^2 hole

 

[HydroMan]

Also, Katara was runnung and shs had free space to move her arms... This idea takes as base that you are stuck in a m^2 hole

You don't necesarry need to run to make an ice ramp construct. Katara was in a hurry situation as there was a battle with the warrios/guards as she didn't had the time to stay in place. And we are talking about waterspring ,not iceramp ,so we arent sure what kind of physical movement she would use for that, so we can't really limit the space as we don't know if she needs freespace to strech her arms or smth or not.

 

[Hero]

You don't necesarry need to run to make an ice ramp construct. Katara was in a hurry situation as there was a battle with the warrios/guards as she didn't had the time to stay in place. And we are talking about waterspring ,not iceramp ,so we arent sure what kind of physical movement she would use for that, so we can't really limit the space as we don't know if she needs freespace to strech her arms or smth or not.

Then why dont we just make this suggestion about an ice ramp. Much easier than explaining what you are trying to do...

 

[paliate]

Couldn't this easily suggest that she used some of the river's water? I mean the ramp is obviously using more water then what can be contained in that small bottle.

 

[Hero]

Couldn't this easily suggest that she used some of the river's water? I mean the ramp is obviously using more water then what can be contained in that small bottle.

Look at that alittle bit closer. In the gif I gave you, it clearly shows that its an ice ramp from her bottle....

 

[HydroMan]

Look at that alittle bit closer. In the gif I gave you, it clearly shows that its an ice ramp from her bottle....

Theorictly ,the water could be used both: and from the skin ,and partly from the river

 

[HydroMan]

Then why dont we just make this suggestion about an ice ramp. Much easier than explaining what you are trying to do...

am not suggesting for the ramp