• Hello Guest! Did you know that ProjectKorra has an official Discord server? A lot of discussion about the official server, development process, and community discussion happens over there. Feel free to join now by clicking the link below.

    Join the Discord Server

Move

Green

Green

Verified Member
haha jk this isn't a move it is a short rant.

Ok for real this is the most closed minded group of people I have basically ever seen. "It's not canon!" NO ONE CARES IF IT WASNT EXACTLY SHOWN IN THE SHOW!!!!! You can make up your own move and it wasn't shown in the show. Bending is about coming up with a new way to use your element everyday. All I am saying is be more open minded the non canon moves

And also just because a move isn't that elements "style" doesn't mean it isn't a benders style!

*Drops mic
 
Hero

Hero

Verified Member
Green said:
haha jk this isn't a move it is a short rant.

Ok for real this is the most closed minded group of people I have basically ever seen. "It's not canon!" NO ONE CARES IF IT WASNT EXACTLY SHOWN IN THE SHOW!!!!! You can make up your own move and it wasn't shown in the show. Bending is about coming up with a new way to use your element everyday. All I am saying is be more open minded the non canon moves

And also just because a move isn't that elements "style" doesn't mean it isn't a benders style!

*Drops mic
Click to expand...
Pfft, this isnt a rant-its spam. If you want to see a real rant, go look up Canon Limits Creativity by me.
 
jedk1

jedk1

New Member
This is why addons exists. PK Core is meant to be canon, or, as canon as possible. Addons can do what ever they want. Also saying that something doesnt match an elements style... Yeah they kinda do ngl. Each element is based on a fighting style. Saying that it has a different fighting style is weird.
 
Sorin

Sorin

Verified Member
Salty mate? - http://projectkorra.com/threads/screech.4293/#post-58360

You shouldn't get angry over something like this. I have been angry about a few of my suggestions being denied as well, but I realized that the concept designers know what they are doing, and what direction the plugin is going. You need to look at it this way, not everyone is gonna agree with you, its life, but calling people closed minded is not the way to go about things. I personally disagree with the suggestion you made as well, it just wouldn't fit into bending very well at all, does this make me closed minded? No. It is just the simple fact that I have an opinion, and I'm sure you do too. But I do also agree, not everything has to be canon, but we should use the show as a guideline, so we don't end up with woodbending for earth benders, you know, because they are EARTH benders! You should really appreciate the fact that this is focused on canon though, as it stops the plugin from becoming a mess. Canon is honestly a good thing when you think about it, without the plugin being canon, why would this even be called ProjectKorra? It would be some weird magic plugin, and im pretty sure the last thing the community wants is a Non-canon, messy plugin that in no way represents what "The legend of korra" was. But hey, this is my opinion, and I can understand if you disagree.

- Sorin <3
 
Green

Green

Verified Member
You really think it was just because of that one post?!? No it is every post and it is ridiculous! I AM NOT SAYING THAT EARTH CAN BEND WOOD!! I am saying that so many things are being denied for one reason only "This wasn't on the show". Well you know what some of us want something new and innovative instead of something copied straight from a show. So please people stop saying "this isn't canon!" Please be open minded and think "oh this exact move wasn't in the show but it is probably possible."
 
Sorin

Sorin

Verified Member
Green said:
You really think it was just because of that one post?!? No it is every post and it is ridiculous! I AM NOT SAYING THAT EARTH CAN BEND WOOD!! I am saying that so many things are being denied for one reason only "This wasn't on the show". Well you know what some of us want something new and innovative instead of something copied straight from a show. So please people stop saying "this isn't canon!" Please be open minded and think "oh this exact move wasn't in the show but it is probably possible."
Click to expand...
You obviously missed what I said completely.
 
MeskenasBoii

MeskenasBoii

Verified Member
Green said:
You really think it was just because of that one post?!? No it is every post and it is ridiculous! I AM NOT SAYING THAT EARTH CAN BEND WOOD!! I am saying that so many things are being denied for one reason only "This wasn't on the show". Well you know what some of us want something new and innovative instead of something copied straight from a show. So please people stop saying "this isn't canon!" Please be open minded and think "oh this exact move wasn't in the show but it is probably possible."
Click to expand...
"Probably possible" is what you must think when you are creating an idea for a new or existing move. Also, when I say "It isn't canon" I mean that it is non-canon in any form or shape, not that it is restrictedly by the creator's detailed description. Let's take the ability screech for an example. Now ask ourselves, is it probably possible for an airbender to use the sound in a offensive manner? The only time we saw soundbending in use when Aang tried to call Appa through the whistle. That isn't an good canon example to state that airbenders can create sound to use it as offensive attack, because there is no evidence to that.

Green said:
And also just because a move isn't that elements "style" doesn't mean it isn't a benders style!
Click to expand...
But the "bending style" what makes the bending art element unique and canon. I know now you don't like me saying the word "canon", but this is what the plugin is based of. Like how there was a homepage with the description below the logo saying "Bridging the minecraft and avatar (not the alien-movie) community together". Well would the plugin based of the ALOK/ATLA minecraft were the bending arts aren't even created with proper conception: Waterbending being the element of mobility, Earthbending all about destruction, Firebending being the element of change, and Airbending being stubborn.
 
Last edited:
Sorin

Sorin

Verified Member
Meskenas-Chi_Blockeris said:
"Probably possible" is what you must think when you are creating an idea for a new or existing move. Also, when I say "It isn't canon" I mean that it is non-canon in any form or shape, not that it is restrictedly by the creator's detailed description. Let's take the ability screech for an example. Now ask ourselves, is it probably possible for an airbender to use the sound in a offensive manner? The only time we saw soundbending in use when Aang tried to call Appa through the whistle. That isn't an good canon example to state that airbenders can create sound to use it as offensive attack, because there is no evidence to that.


But the "bending style" what makes the bending art element unique and canon. I know now you don't like me saying the word "canon", but this is what the plugin is based of. Like how there was a homepage with the description below the logo saying "Bridging the minecraft and avatar (not the alien-movie) community together". Well would the plugin based of the ALOK/ATLA minecraft were the bending arts aren't even created with proper conception: Waterbending being the element of mobility, Earthbending all about destruction, Firebending being the element of change, and Airbending being stubborn.
Click to expand...
aang blew into the whistle with airbending, it wasn't sound bending at all.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top