WaterAbility: IceWall

paliate · Mar 19, 2015

Because i have an opinion i'm acting like a concept designer?
Yes this thread was made before icewall but icewall is out now and it's pretty much just a un-needed version of icewall.
You want a wider icewall? Ask for a config option, Are you lazy? Then just make multiple icewalls and call it wider.

Honestly i'm sick of people getting defensive when their's an opinion they don't like about their move.

Simplicitee · Mar 19, 2015

coastyo said:
Because i have an opinion i'm acting like a concept designer?
Yes this thread was made before icewall but icewall is out now and it's pretty much just a un-needed version of icewall.
You want a wider icewall? Ask for a config option, Are you lazy? Then just make multiple icewalls and call it wider.

Honestly i'm sick of people getting defensive when their's an opinion they don't like about their move.

Not because you have an opinion, but because of the way you say your opinion.

paliate · Mar 19, 2015

White_Knight28 said:
Not because you have an opinion, but because of the way you say your opinion.

I still stand by what i said, this IS carbogens icewall with a different shape, It's ridiculous.

Simplicitee · Mar 19, 2015

This one has a prettier shape.

paliate · Mar 19, 2015

White_Knight28 said:
This one has a prettier shape.

Exactly, Other then that it's an already existing addon, Which is why i believe it will not be made.
I don't remember projectkorra ever doing a move that was basically a addon already.

Simplicitee · Mar 19, 2015

coastyo said:
Exactly, Other then that it's an already existing addon, Which is why i believe it will not be made.
I don't remember projectkorra ever doing a move that was basically a addon already.

Earthsmash, suffocate, flight

Of Light Rain · Mar 19, 2015

White_Knight28 said:
This one has a prettier shape.

GG, add it. 110% superior.

Simplicitee · Mar 19, 2015

Of Light Rain said:
GG, add it. 110% superior.

Exactly. Thank you for understanding.
Yes I see the sarcasm

paliate · Mar 20, 2015

White_Knight28 said:
Earthsmash, suffocate, flight

"Ever DOING a move that is a addon"
I never said they haven't put moves that were addons into Core, I said i've never seem them remake a move and then put it into core, which is basically what this post is wanting them to do.

Simplicitee · Mar 20, 2015

coastyo said:
"Ever DOING a move that is a addon"
I never said they haven't put moves that were addons into Core, I said i've never seem them remake a move and then put it into core, which is basically what this post is wanting them to do.

They remade all those moves... And this is different from the addon icewall due to appearance and use.

Sorin · Mar 20, 2015

White_Knight28 said:
They remade all those moves... And this is different from the addon icewall due to appearance and use.

Agreed

Finn_Bueno_ · Mar 20, 2015

White_Knight28 said:
They remade all those moves... And this is different from the addon icewall due to appearance and use.

Yup. This one knocks back your enemies, can go over land, and provides more protection.

By your logic, airswipe and airsweep are too similar to be added too, so should 1 of those be removed ?

Sorin · Mar 20, 2015

Plus this ability spikes out and curves.

Simplicitee · Mar 20, 2015

finnbon said:
Yup. This one knocks back your enemies, can go over land, and provides more protection.

By your logic, airswipe and airsweep are too similar to be added too, so should 1 of those be removed ?

I dunno m8

paliate · Mar 20, 2015

White_Knight28 said:
They remade all those moves... And this is different from the addon icewall due to appearance and use.

I don't believe they remade them (I believe a few edits were made and then they added it into PK core, same with suffocate2 they took it from the addon section and edited it then added it to core to my belief), And just because it LOOKS different doesn't mean it is.

Soarinsorin said:
Plus this ability spikes out and curves.

Yes, the appearance is different but the move isn't.

finnbon said:
Yup. This one knocks back your enemies, can go over land, and provides more protection.

By your logic, airswipe and airsweep are too similar to be added too, so should 1 of those be removed ?

Were either of those addons and already made?

Okay so lets say someone made a move called IceBomb and added it into the addon section and someone requested it but the bomb was a different shape, do you really think projectkorra would remake a addon that is already out there? In my opinion no because it's a waste of time.

Finn_Bueno_ · Mar 20, 2015

coastyo said:
I don't believe they remade them (I believe a few edits were made and then they added it into PK core, same with suffocate2 they took it from the addon section and edited it then added it to core to my belief), And just because it LOOKS different doesn't mean it is.

Yes, the appearance is different but the move isn't.

Were either of those addons and already made?

Okay so lets say someone made a move called IceBomb and added it into the addon section and someone requested it but the bomb was a different shape, do you really think projectkorra would remake a addon that is already out there? In my opinion no because it's a waste of time.

No, because it only has a different shape. This move is different from @Carbogen's IceWall.

Sorin · Mar 20, 2015

coastyo said:
I don't believe they remade them, And just because it LOOKS different doesn't mean it is.

Yes, the appearance is different but the move isn't.

Were either of those addons and already made?

Okay so lets say someone made a move called IceBomb and added it into the addon section and someone requested it but the bomb was a different shape, do you really think projectkorra would remake a addon that is already out there? In my opinion no because it's a waste of time.

If it was better looking and had better functionality yeah most likely. But then again what am I to say mr.buzzkill. Why you gotta be so negitive on something that is well thought out and was there before "ice wall" came out. Like this move would add alot more movement to the "ice subelement" and as well look frekin awesome.

Finn_Bueno_ · Mar 20, 2015

Soarinsorin said:
If it was better looking and had better functionality yeah most likely. But then again what am I to say mr.buzzkill. Why you gotta be so negitive on something that is well thought out and was there before "ice wall" came out. Like this move would add alot more movement to the "ice subelement" and as well look frekin awesome.

Actually, I've never seen coastyo being nice about anything. He's always negative when someone wants to add something new.

Sorin · Mar 20, 2015

finnbon said:
Actually, I've never seen coastyo being nice about anything. He's always negative when someone wants to add something new.

Hmmm, seems bias to think that way.

Joeri · Mar 20, 2015

coastyo said:
I still stand by what i said, this IS carbogens icewall with a different shape, It's ridiculous.

Expect you know, this one has different mechanics, knockback, damage when its formed and not shatterd

Just cuz they are walls doesnt mean they are exactly the same